Google excludes scheduled maintenance from its Google Apps SLA, but not Google App Engine

Back in July of 2010, I wrote about how Cloud Service Providers exclude scheduled downtime from their service level agreements.  Last Friday, Google made a significant change to their SLA for Google Apps by removing scheduled downtime from their Google Apps SLA:

• Exclusion of scheduled downtime from availability SLA
• Exclusion of intermittent downtime (periods of less than 10 minutes) from availably SLA

Obviously, it is good news for Google Apps customers.  It highlights Google’s infrastructure & operational maturity (in this case, for Google Apps specifically).  

I also think the announcement is important, because it sets a higher standard for service delivery.  By raising the bar, Google also intensifies competitive pressure on service providers such as Microsoft to offer more robust Cloud services.  Ultimately, both customers & the industry should benefit from this.

However, as I discussed in my July post, for infrastructure & platform services such as Google App Engine for Business, scheduled maintenance still remains excluded in all SLAs:

• GAE: http://code.google.com/appengine/business/sla.html
• AWS: http://aws.amazon.com/agreement/
• Azure: http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/en/details.aspx?FamilyID=72193dd2-eeaa-4054-93f6-f6b725cf76af&displaylang=en#QuickDetails
• RackSpace: http://www.rackspacecloud.com/legal/sla/
• GoGrid: http://www.gogrid.com/legal/sla.php
• …

It is 2011.  If we mark the beginning of Cloud Computing by the initial public release of EC2 (2006), I think enough time has passed for Cloud service providers to do a better job of managing planned outages in a non-service-disruptive way. 

--------
Sidebar - I am a regular user of AWS, GAE, Force.com… I have been using these services for more than a couple of years.  To be fair, I have never received any emails from any of the major cloud for scheduled downtime.  I have received a few from other service providers.  So, I would say that they are all doing a pretty good job operationally (a lot better than probably what most enterprises would do), and make sure the services are always up, and almost always perform well :-].  So, they just have it in the SLA agreements for legal protection & liability.   

Never-the-less, when it comes to migrating or designing enterprise solutions, depending on the application type and use-case, this can become an issue, and require both technical implementation & operations planning.